Why Catholic and Not Just Christian? | Fr. Gregory Pine & Fr. Bonaventure Chapman
December 27, 2025
Understanding Catholicism & Christianity
The Godsplaining podcast episode entitled, “Why Catholic and Not Just Christian?”, features Fr. Gregory Pine and Fr. Bonaventure Chapman discussing key reasons someone might identify specifically as Catholic rather than broadly Christian. They explore theological, historical, and spiritual foundations of the Catholic faith, emphasizing how Catholic teaching, tradition, and sacramental life shape a Catholic identity. Topics include the role of the Magisterium, the significance of sacraments, the continuity of tradition from the early Church, and how Catholicism understands Christian identity within its doctrinal framework.
More on Catholicism and Christianity
What is the difference between Catholicism and Christianity?
Catholicism is a branch of Christianity, meaning all Catholics are Christian, but not all Christians are Catholic. Catholicism teaches that Jesus founded one visible Church guided by the Magisterium (the teaching authority of the Church) and rooted in Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. Catholics emphasize the seven sacraments, especially the Eucharist, believe in apostolic succession through bishops, and recognize the Pope as the successor of St. Peter. Other Christian traditions may differ in authority, number of sacraments, church structure, and interpretation of Scripture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do Catholics emphasize tradition in addition to the Bible?
Catholics believe that the faith was handed down through both Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition, guided by the Holy Spirit. Tradition helps preserve the Church’s teachings as they were understood and practiced by the earliest Christians.
Do Catholics believe they are the only true Christians?
Catholics believe the fullness of Christian truth subsists in the Catholic Church, while also recognizing that many elements of truth and holiness exist in other Christian communities.
Why do Catholics believe in seven sacraments while other Christians do not?
The conversation touches on prayer, sacraments, and Christian life practices as foundational for spiritual protection, rather than sensationalized ideas about demons.